On why we don’t quite trust it.
“I distrusted, in general, appeals to nostalgia—I loved the past of archives, but there was no era in the past I had any inclination to revisit with my actual human body, being rather fond of it having at least minimal rights and protections.” — Danielle Evans 1

Feiffer, J. (1978)
Preface
I thought I’d do some breakout pieces that dive a little deeper into some topics I think are related to doing any kind of research into temporal engineering or remembering. To continue this hetconning work I’d need to situate it around (and understand its relationship to) things like memory, grief, myth-making, and tradition, among others (Fig. 1). Nostalgia, as it turns out, is a huge can of worms. After researching my way into a notes document of over 26,600 words from over 45 scholars, I was afraid I’d bitten off more than I could chew. But in the wise words of a friend of mine, sometimes there’s nothing else for it but to “bite off more than you can chew, then chew like fuck.”
In that vein, I’ll take this short preface to briefly reflect on and disclose my own feelings about nostalgia before unhinging my jaw and getting on with it.
I have an uncomfortable relationship with nostalgia. I’m not alone, either. I find it politically suspicious. I associate it with a childish rose-tinted regression or a selective and sentimental self-soothing behaviour (which can’t possibly be taken seriously by serious people, right?). Somewhere along the line I’d filed nostalgia under right-wing-coded regressive habits that probably shouldn’t be indulged. As did Karl Marx, Fredric Jameson, Svetlana Boym, and many others. I feel like I’ve been trained to find it distasteful. I know it’s bad for me, and yet I do it anyway! Everyone does. Even if we’re aware of nostalgia’s ability to manipulate us, or its unreliability in narrating the past, we still willingly—sometimes even fondly—indulge in it2.
My hetconned work has recently been concerned with mapping Restorative Past Fantasies: stories about a simpler, purer, more rightful beforetime that could be restored if the correct enemies were defeated. That is very closely related to nostalgia, but it’s not the same thing. I think these fantasies are dangerous because they’re imminently actionable and ready to go, whereas nostalgia lives in the space just before that, as a pre-condition. It’s the mood before the mandate.
In this darker context, it can seem like a pre-discursive ache, lying in wait. But nostalgia can also be tender and full of affection. As Pickering & Keightley (2006)3 point out, “Even momentarily, we are all prey to nostalgia, particularly where a vehicle of personal memory, such as a photograph of a dead parent or lost lover, may touch us emotionally.” Hutcheon and Valdés (2000)4 make the useful distinction that nostalgia isn’t really in the object, as though it’s lurking inside waiting to be felt. The juice is in the response, the times we suddenly feel an emotional weight (or a tug) when past and present collide. Nostalgia becomes politically dangerous once we are taught to blame an enemy for our (perfectly natural) feelings of longing. That’s when it curdles and becomes anti-social.
Nostalgia studies broadly seems (from the outside) like a melange of persistent ironies and contradictions that require constant unpacking. It’s a reaction to modernity but also inherent to modernity. It’s a reaction to technological advancements throughout history but it is also enhanced by those very technologies, which Susan Sontag (1977) points out then leads to the creation of even more new technologies5 and the whole cycle continues. The nostalgia mood is criticised for being overly sentimental and unserious (concerning itself with feelings of deep loss and longing), while the nostalgia mode is simultaneously criticised for taking seriously the rabid consumption of “pastness” as an aesthetic. It would seem we are all nostalgic for a time when we weren’t so nostalgic.
So what’s the deal with nostalgia? Let’s eat.
At the risk of oversimplifying things by attempting to put the word nostalgia’s transformations into some kind of linear canon, I think it’s a useful way to establish how much nostalgia has changed, and explains why the study of it really has no single disciplinary home. Consequently, we get the benefit of multiple perspectives from a range of fields and methodological traditions.
Nostalgia started out largely being studied (by doctors and psychologists) as an illness, then it was acknowledged (by sociologists and cultural studies theorists) as an important part of both private and group identity formation and meaning-making, before reaching its current terminal velocity where media studies scholars frequently bemoan how nostalgia has become reproducible and commodified, to the point of provoking a reflexive disgust (or at the least a suspicion) in many audiences.
These multiple perspectives over time make it clear nostalgia is and has been many different things, and deserves to be treated as more than an aesthetic or some fishy sentimental indulgence we should really try and train ourselves out of feeling. We can learn a lot from our longings and what triggers our memories, can we not? We communicate so much when we perform our reminiscences for others, and when we situate ourselves in our current moment, we can measure ourselves against the versions of us in the past. As Nicola Sayers argues in “The Promise of Nostalgia: Reminiscence, Longing and Hope in Contemporary American Culture” (2020)6, yearnings and longings that seem particularly “out of kilter” with the present can serve as important clues to understanding our present. Nostalgia reveals what feels untenable right now compared to our past. Nostalgia can both steady and unsteady a shaken self. It can uncover hopes and losses we’re feeling that we don’t yet understand; but it can also unsettle the story that the self tells about itself.

The ick
Progressives can be especially skeptical of nostalgia, almost reflexively. The very word we associate with the advancement of the leftist project—“progressive”—refers to having a concern with the future, while their rivals, “the conservatives” are dutifully looking towards retention and the past (Natali, 20047; Golding, 2019)8. If we make the mistake of putting nostalgia in opposition to utopia then it must be looked down upon by those who work toward progressive social change. But in doing so, we risk losing our connection to the as-yet-unachieved goals of activists past, what Sayers calls “the gold in the rubble”. She describes this as “not nostalgia for what once was, but nostalgia for what is still not… the unfinished promises of yesterday” (Sayers, 2020). Treating nostalgia as frivolous or politically inert kneecaps its useful role in the utopian imagination. Before people can picture a different future, they must measure themselves against their past and those who came before them. In my opinion it’s also what makes nostalgia worth studying: quite simply, the losses people perceive will shape the futures they seek to build.
Mark Fisher’s writing on lost futures goes even further. Sometimes what we feel nostalgic for in the past is the future that still seemed possible from all the way back there. His “slow cancellation of the future”9 describes the dwindling sense that culture or politics might ever produce anything genuinely new, leaving us surrounded by the rubble of futures that never arrived. This nostalgia is a grief of possibilities foreclosed.
Owen Hatherley also wrote about a nostalgia for the future. In his book Militant Modernism (2009)10 he describes it as “a longing for the fragments of the half-hearted post-war attempt at building a new society, an attempt that lay in ruins by the time I was born” lamenting “We have been cheated out of the future, yet the future’s ruins lie about us, hidden or ostentatiously rotting.”
“So what would it mean, then, to look for the future’s remnants? Can we, should we, try and excavate utopia?” – Owen Hatherley
Alastair Bonnett wrote in Left in the Past: Radicalism and the Politics of Nostalgia (2010)11 that “any study of the relationship between nostalgia and radicalism is a study of dilemmas,”12 and that “Until recently one could say almost anything about nostalgia, as long as it was damning”13 He argues further that nostalgia is actually integral to radicalism, and critics who scoff at the notion “do not offer analysis but gestures of disdain; gestures that speak to and rely on a readership who are already firmly convinced that nostalgia is conservative and, hence, suspect.”14 He identifies this criticism as mostly being either self-consciously embarrassed, or based in a prickly skepticism about what role such a subjective emotion could play in the leftist imaginary. Sayers (2020)15 grounds the activist’s task in transforming “mood into matter.” There’s nothing inherently progressive about that conversion, and the right has been learning how to do it, too.
The more I researched nostalgia the more I laboured under this kind of mud-slinging Bonnett was talking about. In writings after the 70s, some scholars were treating it almost like a crime, or an intellectual or creative transgression, like something that was done to people rather than felt by them. Before that it was pathologised and treated like a disease. But to understand how nostalgia became such a suspicious object, we need to go back.
Nostalgia’s origins
Many scholars credit Swiss doctor Johannes Hofer with coining the term nostalgia, by combining the Greek nostos (home) with algos (pain) in his dissertation studying the phenomenon in 1688, but the French term ‘maladie du pays’ actually precedes Hofer’s by 30 years. The first documented English usage is from the diaries of naturalist Joseph Banks16, during the imperial voyage that enabled Britain’s colonisation of Australia on Captain Cook’s HMS Endeavour.
It’s worth pausing over where both of these early accounts located nostalgia: among people sent far from home in the service of violent military and imperial projects. This means nostalgia entered modern knowledge as a disorder in the martial man specifically, spurred on by a psychic revolt to the engagement of prolonged violence. Military doctors in the American Civil War described nostalgic soldiers as weak-willed and insufficiently manly (Anderson & Anderson, 1984)17. The body recoiling from the horrors of war was then medicalised into evidence of a personal flaw in the man, which is a very convenient deflection for the institutions that sent him there. No wonder we’ve been suss on nostalgia, duplicity has been baked in from the start.
From there, nostalgia moved largely into the realm of psychiatry and remained predominantly there until the 1950s. Fred Davis notes in Yearning for Yesterday: A Sociology of Nostalgia (1979)18 that the word nostalgia was regarded around this time as a bit of a “fancy word” confined mainly “to psychiatrists, academic psychologists, and relatively few cultivated lay speakers” but in keeping with its previous transformations over time (such as demilitarisation, and then demedicalisation after that) it was soon to see a rapid uptake in the general population and transform once more, “undergoing a process of “depsychologization””19 as well.
Throughout these transformations (and as we barrel down towards cultural and media studies weighing in on it all) it becomes clear that the “homesickness” part of nostalgia is fading with each new form. By the 1970s, as Paul Grainge writes in Monochrome memories: Nostalgia and style in retro America, there was a burgeoning “culture of nostalgia” created in the wake of the rapid social changes of the 1960s, as well as “a growing media culture feeding upon its own creations” and the “broad commodification of memory within film, fashion, architectural design and the heritage industry.”20 Through popular media, nostalgia had moved from sentiment to style. Nostalgia is quite literally, not what it used to be (Higson, 2014)21.
This presents something of a schism in studying nostalgia in a postmodern context, that of nostalgic mood and the nostalgia mode. Writers and scholars of nostalgia have seemingly fallen over themselves to try and properly differentiate between different types of nostalgia, with some holding more water than others.
Svetlana Boym (2008)22 had two main categories for nostalgia; restorative, and reflective. Tannock (1995)23 categorised between retreat and retrieval. Pickering and Keightley (2006)24 separated nostalgia for “ontological security”, from that of renewal. Fred Davis (1979)25 took a more sociological approach and categorised types of nostalgia as three stages an individual could move through, similar to models of mediated encoding/decoding we see now; First order nostalgia (simple nostalgia), second order (reflexive nostalgia), and third order (interpreted nostalgia). Paul Grainge (2002)26 seems to have the categorisation that continues to fit snugly despite the transformations nostalgia has gone through over the years, drawing a line between (and expanding upon) Jameson’s nostalgia mode, and that of the nostalgic mood.
Grainge uses the idea of the “nostalgia mode” in a way that departs from Jameson, namely rejecting “the assumption of amnesia and historicist crisis”27 Jameson fretted about, instead wanting to run head-on into considering “the memory politics of stylized pastness”. While Jameson drifts into Eeyoring about the “indiscriminate pastiche that distinguishes late capitalism”, Grainge argues that “Jameson fails to account for memory and identity being negotiated by the nostalgia mode… he gives little sense that meaningful narratives of history or cultural memory can be produced through the recycling and/or hybridization of past styles”. I found his categorisation (and expansion on Jameson’s work) to be the most persuasive. If only I felt any compulsion to try and categorise every different instance of nostalgia into its own little home. Sayers seems less inclined to play this sorting game as well, preferring to emphasise the importance of doing “the complicated work of drawing out the utopian potential from within seemingly regressive phenomena”28 instead.
I could waste a long time testing and stretching a whole bunch of these categories to find the One Nostalgia To Break Them All, but I’m about as enthused by that prospect as Sayers in the grand scheme of things. Even trying to narrow it down to simple questions of “who uses nostalgia, why, and when” is an entire book’s worth of work. I’m interested specifically in how nostalgia makes the leap from a private feeling to an effective political tool, and how mediating institutions and media systems facilitate and encourage that shift. How does that ache get worked on?
There’s a strange scale problem in the nostalgia scholarship I’ve been looking at. Psychologists often encounter it as an autobiographical emotion, while cultural theorists encounter it once it’s already become an aesthetic or political rhetoric. I’m interested in the missing middle: what shepherds private longing into collective meaning?
Davis asked this question before social media even existed. How do individually felt anxieties become shared enough to produce a collective nostalgia? Forty-five years later, the machinery available to do that is way more elaborate. Pickering and Keightley (2006)29 point out our relationship to the past depends on how all traces of it are mediated and circulated. That question of mediation is where things get interesting, and if we’re talking about mediation then it’s impossible not to acknowledge…
The Stuart Hall of it all
Stuart Hall’s encoding/decoding model is useful here because it rejects the idea that media messages simply travel perfectly intact between sender and receiver. Hall argued that making meaning is a practice, “a social production,” and that “The world has to be made to mean.”30 Messages are encoded and disseminated to an audience, and members of that audience might broadly accept the preferred meaning, negotiate with it, or oppose it altogether; the important point is that communication is a process of struggle and contestation.
I think the sticky persistence of Hall’s model through seismic changes in the media landscape (and in media technologies) is evidence of its intellectual rigour. Modern social media platforms blur the lines between consumer and creator (Fuchs, 2014)31, but rather than Hall’s model collapsing under the weight of this dynamic, he saw it coming even back in 1980: “The audience is both the ‘source’ and the ‘receiver’ of the television message” (Hall, 1980, p. 119)32.
Adrienne Shaw (2017)33 extends Hall’s model towards the digital platforms themselves, arguing they’re responsible for encoding the possibilities and constraints upon how users can act, and then (as Hall suggests) the users will then interpret, exploit, or resist those fixed possibilities in turn. Matthew Flisfeder (2021)34 adds that users continuously feed platforms new content and even their own behavioural data, which are then analysed and used to further influence what the system volleys back.
Dongwook Song’s (2026)35 recent update of Hall’s model has social media in mind as he breaks it down into four distinct processes: de/encoding, where producers use already-collected user data to shape messages; lincoding (a portmanteau of link and coding), where platform algorithms decide how and which users, messages and other users are all connected; affordecoding, where users learn to work within the affordances of a given platform; and en/decoding, where the users themselves then create, recirculate and reinterpret messages that are intended for others. They all describe a landscape a little more complicated than Hall’s original model, where producers, users, platform companies and the algorithms they make are all continually shuffling and bumping around and adjusting and reacting to one another in real time.
Platforms can now identify and quantify which memories produce engagement. So successful forms of longing can therefore be measured, optimised and, ultimately, deliberately reproduced for propagandistic ends.
Hetconning
All this is to say, by the time nostalgia becomes politically useful online, it’s already been thoroughly worked on. By the time it appears in a feed, it has already been formatted by platforms, quantified and analysed, exposed to social scrutiny, and folded into systems that make the decision to reward some memories with visibility while allowing others to disappear. Jacobsen and Beer (2021)36 call this quantified nostalgia, describing how social media platforms turn memories into objects that can be resurfaced, liked, ranked, shared and compared, and how those metrics can in turn alter the meaning (and, upsettingly, emotional value) users attach to the past. This means online nostalgia is received in a fundamentally different way to other kinds of nostalgia. Deborah Lupton’s work on “data selves”37 pushes the same argument beyond personal memory, treating online affect as something continually made through ongoing relations between people, platforms, interfaces and data. Posting, liking, commenting and sharing mediate, amplify and reshape our feelings.
Neimeyer & Keightley (2020)38 studied a Facebook group called “DoYouRemember” as an example of what they call “nostalgia businesses.” These businesses not only exploit nostalgic texts as a way to maintain audience engagement online, but crucially these audiences are also positioned as labour actors themselves as moderators of that group, “policing [the] communicative nostalgic environment in the interests of protecting advertising revenue” which then has the potential to “promote a conservative political (and explicitly political) agenda.” The concept of a ‘safe space’ was hijacked and co-opted (from its origins in genuine attempts at community building) to that of protecting advertising revenue over all else. This kind of commodification of the process of nostalgising on digital platforms is already in train and already being used to propagandise. The commercial interests of the platforms eat the tail of the user, who in turn feels a part of the platform, creating a kind of digital ouroboros that Tanner (2020)39 argues in The Circle of the Snake: Nostalgia and Utopia in the age of Big Tech can only be killed by the “heat death of fascism” and an “urgent and necessary reckoning with Big Tech”.
The imagined past circulated by these systems doesn’t even need to be coherent. Once nostalgia is produced and mediated the question becomes what fragments of history are rising to the top? How are they selected to give longing a political shape? Tibor Dessewffy (2022)40 calls this “weaponized longing.” His study of Orbán’s Hungary shows that even disparate collages of symbols and historical fragments can be effective, and a usable past can be assembled from whatever victories are available, which is unnerving at best.
This is why I keep digging around in nostalgia instead of treating it as a harmless mood or a tacky aesthetic problem. By the time it starts showing up in politics, it’s usually been through several hands, both human and machine. It can be expressed, repeated, dressed up, shared around, argued over, rewarded, monitored, and reshaped before anyone really clocks that it could be dangerous.
Nostalgia continues to change shape. It began as an illness, then became a way of understanding memory and identity, and was then later used to describe a cultural style and commodity. When nostalgia moved online it became measurable. Platforms (and their netizens) can see which memories travel, and which expressions of longing bring people together. And here’s the scary part: if a layperson can figure out which nostalgias get the most attention, imagine what the architects of Project 2025 could get up to with an entire political machine behind them? What if they figured out a way to seed certain nostalgias into certain individuals?
Prosthetic Nostalgia
Naomi Klein’s Guardian article41 mentioning Amy Sodaro’s concept of “prosthetic trauma”42 made something click for me. If mediated experience can produce an affective relationship to a trauma we did not personally live through, could nostalgia work the same way? I went looking to see whether anyone had already written about this kind of “prosthetic nostalgia.” I wasn’t the first person to put those two words together, but the existing usages are either conceptually ambitious without being fully worked through43, or about architecture and physical spaces44. Importantly though, the idea of feeling nostalgic for something you never experienced has absolutely been explored, most popularly by Arjun Appadurai, who called this phenomenon “armchair nostalgia” (1996)45. Marianne Hirsch (1997)46 gets close from another direction, too, with her work on the concept of “postmemory,” describing how traumatic histories can be inherited across generations.
Owen Hatherley’s The Ministry of Nostalgia (2016)47 looks at the strange afterlife of Britain’s wartime imagery under austerity, and how those images have been actively recirculated by subsequent governments to launder austerity. It’s a prosthetic nostalgia for the return of the Blitz spirit, that Keep Calm and Carry On stoicism that betrays a fondness for the virtues that were supposedly forged by ‘making do’, adopting a stiff upper lip and ‘going without’.
It was shocking to learn in his book that the famous “Keep Calm and Carry On” poster so many of us associate with wartime Britain was actually never circulated during World War 2. It was one of three posters designed by the Ministry of Information in 1939 amid fears of a German ground invasion—and it was the only one that didn’t make the cut. It was discarded after the test printing in favour of the two other posters, which contained far more practical advice for an invaded populace:

Perhaps “Keep Calm and Carry On” doesn’t have quite the same “Reginald! The Gerries are here!” energy.
The Keep Calm and Carry On poster didn’t see light again until was discovered in a secondhand bookshop in 2000. By the wake of the Great Recession triggered by the Global Financial Crisis in 2008, it was everywhere, on tea towels, bags, t-shirts and mugs, purchased by people who likely weren’t even alive in the time they were trying to invoke, many of them unaware of the not-so-subtle ominous messaging “explaining why someone (else) was inevitably going to suffer.” Invoking Douglas Coupland’s wonderfully ominous term “legislated nostalgia”48 (the imposition of memories a population never possessed), Hatherley described its use as “a nostalgia for the state of being repressed.”
Hatherley’s austerity nostalgia has something of nostalgie de la boue49 about it, a longing for the mud: the tendency to romanticise hardship and degradation after enough time has passed to paint over all the misery. Wartime austerity gets invoked as proof of admirable national character, a time when hearty communal resolve saw everyone banding together against a shared threat, an appealing (and almost quaint) notion in these times of division and isolation. Instead of appearing cruel for introducing austerity and depriving its constituents of material benefits, the Thatcherites and Blairites of the world can mediate and recycle this nostalgia to convince people they’re actually taking their medicine and it’s good for them.
If prosthetic trauma can travel across generations, can prosthetic nostalgia move in the same ways? You don’t have to have personally lost something for someone to persuade you that it was taken from you, and people don’t need to have shared a past in order to bond over the feeling that they’ve lost the same one. I’m curious about what happens between Coupland’s ‘you are told this is your past’ and the point where we come to feel its absence as our loss.
A prosthetic nostalgia serves to give strangers a common object of longing, and therefore something around which they can recognise each other as a group, effectively turning their longing into be-longing50. Once that imagined past starts doing this identity work, in-group bonding quickly lends itself to inventing a story about who we were, what we had, and why we don’t have it anymore. Which begs the question about who the “they” might be, who is in the out-group?
Doane and Hodges (2013)51 were writing about this dynamic back in the 80s, describing nostalgia as an antifeminist rhetorical practice used by male writers who blamed every problem in contemporary society on the rise of feminist authority, characterising the liberated woman as “implicated in this movement toward degeneracy.” What the nostalgic writer wants, they argue, is fixed and immovable sexual difference, one that keeps women in the home and doesn’t challenge paternal authority: “As feminists, we argue that nostalgic writers construct their visions of a golden past to authenticate woman’s traditional place and to challenge the outspoken feminist criticisms of it.”
These imagined golden pasts and restorative fantasies that I explore with this hetconned project are dependant on making heterosexuality and rigid gender roles and the nuclear family feel like the natural order of things; the original social order from which we have supposedly fallen away. The people being recruited into that story simply cannot have a memory of such a world because no purely heterosexual world has ever existed. When people try and convince others that there was, queerness can then easily be made to look like an alien thing that arrived and devastated something that had previously been perfect and whole. This softens the ground for the next logical step: doing whatever it takes to get back there.
Peroratio
After studying nostalgia for months I have a newfound appreciation for it52. On a bad day, I feel a bratty stubborn refusal to concede the entire concept to the right. I worry that if we slam and dismiss it as sentimental, unserious or reactionary then we’re basically handing it over to people who will use it to do real material harm. We could also be cutting off our nose to spite our face. There’s gold in that there rubble. There are lessons to be learned from fights we’ve previously fought. We can’t afford to forget the unkept promises made to us that were supposed to lead to an exciting future. Unmet needs sit in our longings; there is space for nostalgia in the utopian imaginary.
My main takeaway is that we should interrogate our nostalgia, not surrender it. Ideally, we can hold our nose and bear to sit with it long enough to find whatever unfinished yesterdays might still be useful to the utopian project. Nostalgic longings don’t even have to begin in our own lived memory, they can be planted—or even inherited—so there’s a more defensive reason to pay attention to them, too. A praxis reason: if we don’t pay attention to what people miss, somebody is going to tell them why they miss it.
And you’re not going to like it.
— Leena
- Evans, D. (2021). The Office of Historical Corrections: A Novella and Stories. Penguin. ↩︎
- The robots will not take my em dashes away from me. If you think this means AI wrote this I will point you at the weird disjointed somewhat manic structure of this essay and simply say: AI could never. ↩︎
- Pickering, M., & Keightley, E. (2006). The modalities of nostalgia. Current sociology, 54(6), 919-941. ↩︎
- Hutcheon, L., & Valdés, M. J. (2000). Irony, nostalgia, and the postmodern: A dialogue. Poligrafías. Revista de literatura comparada. Núm. 3. Facultad de Filosofía y Letras, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, México 1998-2000. ↩︎
- “Cameras began duplicating the world at that moment when the human landscape started to undergo a vertiginous rate of change” Pg. 15. Sontag, S. (1977). On Photography. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ↩︎
- Sayers, N. (2020). The Promise of Nostalgia : reminiscence, longing and hope in contemporary American culture (1st ed.). Routledge. ↩︎
- Natali, M. P. (2004). History and the Politics of Nostalgia. Iowa Journal of Cultural Studies, 5(1). ↩︎
- Golding, D. (2019). Star Wars after Lucas: A Critical Guide to the Future of the Galaxy. U of Minnesota Press. ↩︎
- Fisher, M. (2014). Ghosts of my life: Writings on depression, hauntology and lost futures. Simon and Schuster. ↩︎
- Hatherley, O. (2009). Militant Modernism. Simon and Schuster ↩︎
- Bonnett, A. (2010). Left in the past : radicalism and the politics of nostalgia (1st ed.). Continuum. (No ibid in APA, kill me now). ↩︎
- Bonnett, A. (2010). Left in the past : radicalism and the politics of nostalgia (1st ed.). Continuum. Pg. 7. ↩︎
- Bonnett, A. (2010). Left in the past : radicalism and the politics of nostalgia (1st ed.). Continuum. Pg. 3. ↩︎
- Bonnett, A. (2010). Left in the past : radicalism and the politics of nostalgia (1st ed.). Continuum. Pg. 3. ↩︎
- Sayers, N. (2020). The Promise of Nostalgia : reminiscence, longing and hope in contemporary American culture (1st ed.). Routledge. ↩︎
- Banks, J. (1963). The Endeavour Journal of Joseph Banks, 1768-1771 (Vol. 1). Trustees of the Public Library of New South Wales. ↩︎
- Anderson, D. L., & Anderson, G. T. (1984). Nostalgia and Malingering in the Military during the Civil War. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 28(1), 156-166. ↩︎
- Davis, F. (1979). Yearning for yesterday: A sociology of nostalgia. New York. ↩︎
- Davis, F. (1979). Yearning for yesterday: A sociology of nostalgia. New York. Pg. 4. ↩︎
- Grainge, P. (2002). Monochrome memories: Nostalgia and style in retro America. ↩︎
- Higson, A. (2014). Nostalgia is not what it used to be: heritage films, nostalgia websites and contemporary consumers. Consumption Markets & Culture, 17(2), 120-142. ↩︎
- Boym, S. (2008). The Future of Nostalgia. Basic books. ↩︎
- Tannock, S. (1995). Nostalgia critique. Cultural studies, 9(3), 453-464. ↩︎
- Pickering, M., & Keightley, E. (2006). The Modalities of Nostalgia. Current sociology, 54(6), 919-941. ↩︎
- Davis, F. (1979). Yearning for yesterday: A sociology of nostalgia. New York. ↩︎
- Grainge, P. (2002). Monochrome memories: Nostalgia and style in retro America. ↩︎
- Grainge, P. (2002). Monochrome memories: Nostalgia and style in retro America. ↩︎
- Sayers, N. (2020). The Promise of Nostalgia : reminiscence, longing and hope in contemporary American culture (1st ed.). Routledge. (Pg. 82.) ↩︎
- Pickering, M., & Keightley, E. (2006). The Modalities of Nostalgia. Current sociology, 54(6), 919-941. ↩︎
- Hall, S. (2005). The rediscovery of ‘ideology’; return of the repressed in media studies. In Culture, society and the media (pp. 52-86). Routledge. ↩︎
- Fuchs, C. (2021). Social media: A critical introduction. SAGE publications Ltd. ↩︎
- Hall, S. (1980). Encoding/decoding. In S. Hall, D. Hobson, A. Lowe, & P. Willis (Eds.), Culture, media, language working papers in cultural studies, 1972–79 (pp. 117–127). Routledge. ↩︎
- Shaw, A. (2017). Encoding and decoding affordances: Stuart Hall and interactive media technologies. media, culture & society, 39(4), 592-602. ↩︎
- Flisfeder, M. (2021). Algorithmic desire: Toward a new structuralist theory of social media. Northwestern University Press. ↩︎
- Song, D. (2026). Hall’s encoding/decoding model revisited in the digital platform age: de/encoding, lincoding, affordecoding, and en/decoding. Information, Communication & Society, 29(2), 546-564. ↩︎
- Jacobsen, B. N., & Beer, D. (2021). Quantified Nostalgia: Social Media, Metrics, and Memory. Social Media + Society, 7(2) ↩︎
- Lupton, D. (2020). Data Selves: More-than-human perspectives. Cambridge: Polity Press. ↩︎
- Niemeyer, K., & Keightley, E. (2020). The commodification of time and memory: Online communities and the dynamics of commercially produced nostalgia. New Media & Society, 22(9), 1639–1662. ↩︎
- Tanner, G. (2020). The Circle of the Snake: Nostalgia and Utopia in the age of Big Tech. Simon and Schuster. ↩︎
- Dessewffy, T. (2022). Weaponized Longing. Appartenances & Altérités, 2. ↩︎
- Klein, N. (2024, October 5). How Israel has made trauma a weapon of war. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2024/oct/05/israel-gaza-october-7-memorials ↩︎
- Sodaro, A. (2019). Prosthetic trauma and politics in the National September 11 Memorial Museum. Memory Studies, 12(2), 117-129. ↩︎
- Ayres, D. (2021). Prosthetic Nostalgia: Defining and Contextualising New Terminology in Humanities Discourse. (Masters Thesis) ↩︎
- Moon, P. (2021). Prosthetic nostalgia: History and memory in” Art Deco Napier”. Journal of New Zealand Studies, (32), 60-80. ↩︎
- Appadurai, A. (1996). Modernity at large, Minneapolis. Public Worlds. ↩︎
- Hirsch, M. (1997). Family Frames: Photography, narrative, and postmemory. Harvard University Press. ↩︎
- Hatherley, O. (2016). The Ministry of Nostalgia: Consuming Austerity. Verso Books. ↩︎
- Coupland, D. (1991). Generation X: Tales for an accelerated culture. Macmillan. ↩︎
- Davis wrote this term as “nostalgie pour la boue” in Yearning for Yesterday, but the more common usage these days seems to be “nostgalie de la boue”. Either way, mud’s mud. ↩︎
- The red Make America Great Again caps come to mind, but not enough for a painful digression. ↩︎
- Doane, J., & Hodges, D. (2013). Nostalgia and Sexual Difference (RLE Feminist Theory): The Resistance to Contemporary Feminism. Routledge. (First published in 1987) ↩︎
- Even now I feel compelled to add a “kind of” qualifier, because the wince is still strong in this one. ↩︎

Fig. 1. Upcoming areas of concern.
commodification commodified memory curtis yarvin Danielle Evans digital memory digital nostalgia digital platforms encoding decoding Fred Davis grief hannah arendt hetconning heterosexuality homesickness identity identity formation late capitalism Marianne Hirsch Mark Fisher media studies mediation medievalism mencius moldbug modernity myth-making naomi klein nicola sayers nostalgia nostalgia studies nostalgic mood nuclear family paul grainge project 2025 propaganda restorative fantasy restorative nostalgia restorative past fantasy sentimentality social media stuart hall Susan Sontag technofeudalism tradition traditional family values tradwives

Leave a Reply